The do's and don'ts of civil discourse used to include don't shout "You lie" at the President if you're a sitting U.S. congressman and don't jump up on stage, grab her mic away, and then tell the world that some other performer deserved Taylor Swift's MTV Video Music Award. Thankfully, the past few days and hours have shown via social networks that these interruptions are still social taboo.
Sometimes an outburst or a stunt works because it's disruptive. By disruptive, I mean that the event is one that disrupts your focus but attracts your attention. For instance, Lady Gaga's wardrobe changes and Pink's trapeze act at the VMAs were disruptive.
An interruption is entirely different; it takes away your choice and it's in your face whether you want it to be there or not. Television advertising is an interruption (unless it's extremely well done and then it becomes a disruption.) Panhandling is an interruption whereas street performing is a disruption.
Kanye was once an exciting, disruptive artist but now is in danger of just becoming an another interruption in a world where attention is among the highest prized commodities.
Our dinnertime ritual interrupted by a telemarketer, our social media conversations interrupted by an automated self-promotional message, or an email selling us something we don't want for a body part we don't have--like Taylor Swift, we've got a lot of our own Kanyes in our faces ruining our moments, large and small.
During his hasty apology on the Jay Leno Show premier Monday night, West was asked by the host "What would your mother have thought?" (She passed away a year ago.) But West doesn't need his mother to tell him what's right and wrong. He and all brands today have to answer to the wisdom of the crowd--if they'll just shut up long enough to listen.
The beauty of disruption is that it's unexpected but not unwelcome, distracting yet attractive, has shock value but also some value for the targets and not just the celebrity's ego or brand's self-interest. If that sounds like an art, it is one. And it's why stunts run such a high risk of backfiring and, thanks to social media, backlash
OK, enough about Kanye...
9/16/09 - UPDATE: I know I said enough about Kanye but I could resist this YouTube mashup and, while I've got other things to do, clever people have taken Kanye's interruption and turned it into many fine, fun examples of disruptive communication. Examples follow:
Sometimes an outburst or a stunt works because it's disruptive. By disruptive, I mean that the event is one that disrupts your focus but attracts your attention. For instance, Lady Gaga's wardrobe changes and Pink's trapeze act at the VMAs were disruptive.
An interruption is entirely different; it takes away your choice and it's in your face whether you want it to be there or not. Television advertising is an interruption (unless it's extremely well done and then it becomes a disruption.) Panhandling is an interruption whereas street performing is a disruption.
Kanye was once an exciting, disruptive artist but now is in danger of just becoming an another interruption in a world where attention is among the highest prized commodities.
Our dinnertime ritual interrupted by a telemarketer, our social media conversations interrupted by an automated self-promotional message, or an email selling us something we don't want for a body part we don't have--like Taylor Swift, we've got a lot of our own Kanyes in our faces ruining our moments, large and small.
During his hasty apology on the Jay Leno Show premier Monday night, West was asked by the host "What would your mother have thought?" (She passed away a year ago.) But West doesn't need his mother to tell him what's right and wrong. He and all brands today have to answer to the wisdom of the crowd--if they'll just shut up long enough to listen.
The beauty of disruption is that it's unexpected but not unwelcome, distracting yet attractive, has shock value but also some value for the targets and not just the celebrity's ego or brand's self-interest. If that sounds like an art, it is one. And it's why stunts run such a high risk of backfiring and, thanks to social media, backlash
OK, enough about Kanye...
9/16/09 - UPDATE: I know I said enough about Kanye but I could resist this YouTube mashup and, while I've got other things to do, clever people have taken Kanye's interruption and turned it into many fine, fun examples of disruptive communication. Examples follow:
For more examples, check out Mashable.com's Top 10 Kanye Parodies list.
1 comment:
Lovely look at disruption vs. interruption and excellent comparison to Kanye vs. Lady Gaga. As much as I can't stand either, I turned off the TV after the VMAs hating Kanye and intrigued by Gaga, which is exactly what Gaga wants, I'm sure.
Post a Comment